Are you looking to finish your basement but unsure whether to go with traditional methods or a specialized system like Total Basement Finishing? The wrong choice could lead to unexpected costs, moisture issues, or frustrating repairs down the road.
Since 2017, Energy Swing has helped Pittsburgh-area homeowners create beautiful, durable basements. We are Western PA’s only dealer of the Total Basement Finishing system. A moisture-resistant, long-lasting alternative to traditional materials.
Although we specialize in Total Basement Finishing, we recognize that traditional finishing has advantages for some homeowners. Here’s a fair comparison so you can make the best decision for your needs.
By the end of this article, you'll have a clear understanding of the best basement finishing choice for your Pittsburgh home—without the risk of costly mistakes.
What is Total Basement Finishing?
Total Basement Finishing is a specialized system designed for basements. It features moisture-resistant walls, waterproof flooring, and a drop ceiling. Its inorganic materials prevent mold and water damage, offering durability and low maintenance. It is only sold and installed through authorized dealers and is typically sold as the floor, walls, and ceiling system. Although TBF has a higher upfront cost, it provides long-term value with warranties and efficiency.
What is Traditional Basement Finishing?
Traditional basement finishing uses common building materials. For example, drywall and carpet, which allows full design flexibility. It's more budget-friendly upfront, but these materials are not moisture-resistant. They are prone to potential water and moisture damage. Installation can take longer because many contractors handle different sections. An electrician, plumber, and carpenter all do their work separately rather than all as a team. Because of this, maintenance costs may arise over time.
How Much Does It Cost to Finish a Basement—Now and in the Future?
The basement can be a unique space. It often faces problems that other rooms in your home don’t experience. Basements can be musty and moldy and experience water problems. That is why it is important to consider the cost of finishing your basement now, versus the costs that could accumulate over time due to repairs.
Total Basement Finishing
- Higher upfront cost, typically between $30,000 and $100,000.
- Costs are more predictable because of engineered materials and a structured installation process.
- Offers long-term savings by reducing the risk of moisture-related damage and repairs.
- The average basement mold remediation costs range from $500-$3,000.
- The cost of cleaning and restoring a basement is upwards of $3,000.
- Lifetime warranty coverage provides extra financial protection that your project is covered.
Traditional Basement Finishing
- Generally more budget-friendly upfront, with costs varying depending on materials and contractors.
- Prone to unexpected expenses due to design changes, moisture-related issues, or contractor delays.
- Lower initial investment but warranties are not guaranteed for installation of products. Moisture-related repairs or replacements may lead to an increase in long-term costs in the future.
Initial Cost Winner: Traditional basement finishing wins. Materials are readily available at most stores, so they are easy to get and can be installed on your own.
Lifetime Cost Winner: Total Basement Finishing wins. The materials are specially made for the basement environment. You don’t have the risk of water damage and the products and installation are all covered under a warranty.
Which Basement Finishing Option Takes Less Time to Install?
Total Basement Finishing
- Installation usually takes 3-5 weeks. All components are pre-engineered to fit together efficiently.
- One company handles the entire project, ensuring a streamlined process and consistent quality.
- Less disruption to daily life due to a cohesive and organized installation.
Traditional Basement Finishing
- Can take several months to complete. Coordination between several contractors and material availability may cause delays.
- Projects are often completed in phases, leading to potential scheduling delays.
- May need more contractor visits for modifications or unexpected changes.
WINNER: Total Basement Finishing is declared the winner for timeline and convenience. Once the installation team arrives at the job site, they return every day until they finish the project. You can return to your normal home schedule with a disruption that doesn’t last as long.
What Are People Saying?
Comment
byu/Independent_Apple159 from discussion
inpittsburgh
byu/Independent_Apple159 from discussion
inpittsburgh
Ready to see it in real life?
Before, choosing a basement finishing method may have felt overwhelming, with concerns about cost, durability, and long-term maintenance. Now, you have a clear comparison to guide your choice.
Which basement finishing type is right for you?
While there is no one-size-fits-all choice, here’s a quick breakdown to help you decide:
- For homeowners that are looking for the most budget-friendly solution → Traditional Basement Finishing.
- For homeowners concerned with long-term savings against moisture-related damage → Total Basement Finishing.
- For homeowners focused on durability and functionality over extensive customization → Total Basement Finishing.
- For homeowners that want to work with one company from start to finish → Total Basement Finishing.
- For homeowners that want their project started right away → Traditional Basement Finishing.
- New homes without water issues present → Traditional Basement Finishing.
- Basements that currently or have previously experienced water issues or damage → Total Basement Finishing.
The next step? Visit our photo gallery or our Monroeville Design Center to see TBF in action—and when you’re ready, schedule a free consultation to bring your vision to life!